1. Elmo
Estimated Cost: $15–$25* What transpired: A complete Pinterest fail Elmo plays a significant role in many people’s childhoods. Despite his furry monster appearance, this red Muppet from Sesame Street is actually just a toddler’s pal. This is why it’s terrible that the kid’s cake didn’t turn out.
Elmo on Pinterest and @odditymall
After eating this cake, which transformed Elmo into a demonic beast from the depths of hell, it’s no longer Elmo’s world. Given all the signs, we’re not shocked that this was called a “Pinterest fail.”