4. Tickle Me Elmo

Publication year: 1996
Manufacturer: Tyco Toys
* Original Cost: $29.99
Tickle Me Elmo, a plush Sesame Street character with an infectious laugh response, was first released by Tyco Toys in 1996. This adorable red creature, which retailed for $29.99, went viral throughout the Christmas season.

Elmo, tickle me, r/90s_kid/Reddit.
Those who experienced the ticklish delight of this cherished Sesame Street companion will never forget Tickle Me Elmo’s contagious laughter and charming fur.